Key Colony Beach Real Estate Lifestyle Photo 02

Real Estate by Area

Real Estate by Area Main Image

38

Unique Areas

2,637

Listings Available

216

Listings Sold in 2025

01 - Key West
Area

1
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$786
Median Price/Per SqFt

$995,000
Median List Price

01 Key West
Area

145
Listings Available

14
Listings Sold in 2025

$1,096
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,749,500
Median List Price

02 Key West
Area

205
Listings Available

19
Listings Sold in 2025

$1,326
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,695,000
Median List Price

03 Key West
Area

136
Listings Available

13
Listings Sold in 2025

$681
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,197,000
Median List Price

04 Key West
Area

112
Listings Available

13
Listings Sold in 2025

$803
Median Price/Per SqFt

$899,000
Median List Price

05 Stock Island To Shark Key
Area

120
Listings Available

14
Listings Sold in 2025

$490
Median Price/Per SqFt

$775,000
Median List Price

06 Bay Point To Sugarloaf
Area

63
Listings Available

2
Listings Sold in 2025

$807
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,395,000
Median List Price

07 Cudjoe Key
Area

116
Listings Available

8
Listings Sold in 2025

$1,014
Median Price/Per SqFt

$907,450
Median List Price

08 Summerland Key
Area

47
Listings Available

1
Listings Sold in 2025

$1,267
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,297,000
Median List Price

09 Ramrod Key
Area

44
Listings Available

5
Listings Sold in 2025

$693
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,039,000
Median List Price

10 Little | Middle | Big Torch Keys
Area

44
Listings Available

1
Listings Sold in 2025

$786
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,100,000
Median List Price

11 Big Pine Key | No Name Key
Area

149
Listings Available

19
Listings Sold in 2025

$819
Median Price/Per SqFt

$862,500
Median List Price

13 7 Mile Bridge To Sombrero Bch Rd E & W
Area

74
Listings Available

2
Listings Sold in 2025

$575
Median Price/Per SqFt

$812,450
Median List Price

14 Sombrero Area
Area

79
Listings Available

8
Listings Sold in 2025

$693
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,799,000
Median List Price

15 - Sombrero Bch Rd To Vaca Cut Gulfside
Area

1
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$323
Median Price/Per SqFt

$380,000
Median List Price

15 Sombrero Bch Rd To Vaca Cut Gulfside
Area

51
Listings Available

6
Listings Sold in 2025

$1,101
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,249,000
Median List Price

16 Sombrero Bch Rd To Vaca Cut Oceanside
Area

107
Listings Available

7
Listings Sold in 2025

$508
Median Price/Per SqFt

$705,000
Median List Price

17 Vaca Cut Both Sides Holiday Inn | Key Colony
Area

105
Listings Available

11
Listings Sold in 2025

$726
Median Price/Per SqFt

$949,000
Median List Price

18 East Of Holiday Inn Us #1 & Coco Plum
Area

57
Listings Available

5
Listings Sold in 2025

$618
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,075,000
Median List Price

19 Crawl Key & Grassy Key
Area

35
Listings Available

2
Listings Sold in 2025

$596
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,275,000
Median List Price

20 Duck Key | Coral Key | Conch Key
Area

81
Listings Available

4
Listings Sold in 2025

$1,165
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,060,000
Median List Price

21 Long Key
Area

20
Listings Available

1
Listings Sold in 2025

$913
Median Price/Per SqFt

$854,000
Median List Price

22 Lower Matecumbe
Area

73
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$1,950
Median Price/Per SqFt

$2,395,000
Median List Price

23 Upper Matecumbe
Area

54
Listings Available

5
Listings Sold in 2025

$967
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,624,000
Median List Price

24 Windley Key
Area

6
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$1,006
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,662,500
Median List Price

25 Plantation Key
Area

159
Listings Available

21
Listings Sold in 2025

$977
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,050,000
Median List Price

26 Key Largo S Of Mm 96.9
Area

153
Listings Available

7
Listings Sold in 2025

$556
Median Price/Per SqFt

$797,000
Median List Price

27 Key Largo Mm 97 107
Area

359
Listings Available

25
Listings Sold in 2025

$598
Median Price/Per SqFt

$850,000
Median List Price

28 Key Largo N Of Mm 107 Incl Ocean Reef
Area

11
Listings Available

2
Listings Sold in 2025

$11,759
Median Price/Per SqFt

$5,495,000
Median List Price

99 Outside Florida
Area

19
Listings Available

1
Listings Sold in 2025

$487
Median Price/Per SqFt

$750,000
Median List Price

Duck Key, Coral Key, Conch Key
Area

2
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$853
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,412,500
Median List Price

Islamorada
Area

2
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$4
Median Price/Per SqFt

$2,588
Median List Price

Key Largo Mm 97 107
Area

1
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$719
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,895,550
Median List Price

Key West
Area

1
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$705
Median Price/Per SqFt

$1,499,000
Median List Price

Middle Keys
Area

1
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$2
Median Price/Per SqFt

$2,600
Median List Price

Sombrero Bch Rd To Vaca Cut
Area

1
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$1,098
Median Price/Per SqFt

$2,390,000
Median List Price

Stock Island To Shark Key
Area

2
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$0
Median Price/Per SqFt

$0
Median List Price

Upper Matecumbe
Area

1
Listings Available

N/A
Listings Sold in 2025

$734
Median Price/Per SqFt

$745,000
Median List Price